20 replies to this topic

[nightfox]

I sure have learned my lesson of using phpBB on a site of mine that gets many hits. Apparently, the attacker used a SQL injection (my password is 7 characters and is VERY hard to crack) to gain admin access and deleted everything then left his mark.

I don't even know WHY phpBB is allowed to exist and WHY it's so popular... I'm NEVER going to use it again!

Keep away from it!

[N]F

[pyost]

Nothing new on the horizon, unfortunatelly. It is well-known that phpBB is the BBS with most security issues. And with hundreds of cracking tutorials on-line, even a kid could get into phpBB. On the other hand, it would be hard, even for a pro, to crack SMF. In my opinion, it is the best free BBS when it comes to security. It might not be as good-looking and customizable (the number of mods) as phpBB, but it sure is more secure.

[Mafamba Team]

I don't fully understand.

Anyway if you're talking about a phpBB forum, there's no point you should use proboards.

[FunDa]

Isn't there any way to prevent these SQL injection attacks ?

BTW, what is an SQL injection attack ?

I'm using phpBB for my site and I loved the customizability. SMF seemed a little harder to use ( for me at least )

Isn't there any way we can make phpBB safer ???

[Niru]

Hope, the phpBB team will come up with a solution to avoid these SQL injection attacks!
I'm also using phpbb for my forum!
like it very much as it is the simplest forum and easy to maintain than any other bullettin boards!
I like the simple interface also!

BTW, what is an SQL injection attack ?

SQL injection is a security vulnerability that occurs in the database layer of an application. The vulnerability is present when user input is either incorrectly filtered for string literal escape characters embedded in SQL statements or user input is not strongly typed and thereby unexpectedly executed.

SQL injection is a technique used to take advantage of non-validated input vulnerabilities to pass SQL commands through a Web application for execution by a backend database. Attackers take advantage of the fact that programmers often chain together SQL commands with user-provided parameters, and can therefore embed SQL commands inside these parameters. The result is that the attacker can execute arbitrary SQL queries and/or commands on the backend database server through the Web application.

You can see more about that here, here and also here

How to avoid SQL Injection >> Read it here & here

Edited by pyost, 23 September 2006 - 09:25 PM.

[Opethian]

This is very alarming.

I've been deciding which setup to go to and this must be the third instance I've heard about phpBB getting SQL injhected (if that's a term being used now).

So I guess I'm left with SMF then. Is there any other free forum out there that's noteworthy that anyone here can recommend?

[Mark420]

Bad luck Nightfox...I feel for you..must have been terrible to login and find your board contents gone ;((

Did you have a backup in anyway?

[Quatrux]

Because phpbb is so popular for a long time now, a lot of whom know the source code and know how it works, so if you know how it works, you can always mess it up, don't you? Eventually, I read that SMF is much more secure to exploits and sql injections, because it is coded differently than phpbb, but people who is used to use phpbb - they have difficulties of moving to other forums such as SMF or don't have enough income to buy IPB or vBulletin.. They defend phpbb and say that those sites which get successful attacks didn't configure it the way it needs to be configured + the server configuration is bad and etc. It would be best to create your own forum system, but it just takes time and why waste the time if somebody else wrote it?

There are more forum software written but not so popular, so they might be more secure, but with less features and modifications + skins. I myself wanted to use phpbb, but as it is so vulnerable to exploits, I never did it, but I think I will use Phorum, which is available for a long time, but new versions are available now and I hope it will suit my needs.. I just need a very customizable forum software written in php which would work with mysql database.

[HM-BRazil Owner]

oh ****! I ever used phpBB ... * gulp* well ... then i'll use phpbb 3 ; it's much more secure!

BTW i don't like smf , don't have money for IPB or VB... :/

[richie]

Phpbb is a very good forum with its lot of moda ehich i love to use,but these sql injection are increasing ,i have heard many webmasters facing the same problem ,the phpbb team has to do something about it,its really stupid that the most famous forum software is the one with the most security holes .
but again its like ie ,the more famous,the more hackers try to find security holes in it.

[mnur183]

owwhh....i was wondering to used phpbb...is it really that this script so easy to stole...... can anyone give me a script that really safe for my new coming forum...)

[WeaponX]

owwhh....i was wondering to used phpbb...is it really that this script so easy to stole...... can anyone give me a script that really safe for my new coming forum...)

It's not about the script being stolen or anything like that, it's about being exploited due to the security holes it has. The developers at phpBB need to patch up these exploits as quickly as they can. The last time I read up about this, they weren't quick on their part...so I guess many had problems already.

If you want a "good" forum, try out Simple Machines Forum at:

http://www.simplemachines.org

They usually patch up the security holes very quickly...sometimes even before it's known to the public (lots of forum testers ).

[HellFire121]

I've always stood away from phpBB, even its lightweight feature list is enough for me.
All the sites you see that have been hacked have most likely used phpBB, there are quite a few alternatives and i'd say any of them would be better than phpBB.

You can go here: http://www.opensourcecms.com and check out the forum demos on the site.

-HellFire

[ethergeek]

I just recently switched my forums from phpbb3 to the latest SMF. I didn't have many posts on it anyway, so I figured I'd try it out. Everyone I've asked ranks SMF 3rd behind vB and IPB, so I figured it was worth a shot.

Anyway, I'm having fun with SMF so far; everything is easier with it, and there's alot of features that work out of the box with SMF that I have to spend a few hours modding phpbb to get. I may try phpbb3 again when there are some decent mods out for it, but until then, I'm sticking with SMF.

[lifetalk]

I've been thru a similar situation. Basically, i guess the hacker managed to get into my hosting account. Messed with my SQL database, and then, each time i loaded the forum, it redirected to his page where he left his mark. Sad.

I've learnt my lesson too. And now, i use vBulletin, far more secure. Way secure!

[diyar]

It Happened to me as well My phpbb forum site was hacked too!! I believe the security problem is sorted out in phpbb 3!!!

I would recommend people to avoid using phpbb 2 as well!!!

Regards

[tyƒoon™]

So can you still do that same hack on phpBB3 or not?

i'm kinda dubble sided as to what software i should use for my new forums. I have both experiences with phpBB and SMF. I was considering phpBB3 now so my new forums. Does anyone want to back phpBB3 or still reccomend me to go for SMF?

[diyar]

I would recommend you to stay with SMF because hardly anyone is using PhpBB 3 and we dont know if it has any security issues but i'm sure its going to be much safer than PhpBB2!!

I'll say stick with SMF

[WeaponX]

The problem with phpBB is that they sort of have a bad reputation for keeping up to date with their security issues....at least from what I read from other phpBB users. SMF is usually really quick on the trigger and the patches are deployed and installed usually with just two clicks or so.