Please Vote On The Design For My New Website Logo! The Entries For The 30 Credit Logo Design Challenge.

	Please Vote On The Design For My New Website Logo! - The Entries For The 30 Credit Logo Design Challenge.
	Discussion by vujsa with 22 Replies. Last Update: June 22, 2007, 10:59 am (View Latest)	Page 1 of 2 pages.

vujsa

A little over a month ago, I issued a challenge to the members of AstaHost to design a logo for my website, Handy PHP. The winner or winners could receive as much a 30 hosting credits from my credit bank if their design is selected to be used. Well, it didn't get too much attention until I moved it to another forum. If you would like more information on the challenge, please read the original topic: 30 Credit Logo Design Challenge!, Design A New Logo For Handy PHP And Win 30 Hosting Credits

Please review each of the entries and cast your vote. Some of the resolution could have been compromised as I had to combine the images into one per entry since there is a limit on the number of attachments in a single post. The images are also probably scaled down to fit so you'll have to click on them or view the original topic to see them in full size.

Please feel free to leave your comments as to why you voted how you did but please be sensitive to the feelings of the designers that submitted their work. It only makes it more difficult to get people to offer their ideas if they are afraid to be ridiculed!

Anyway, here are the entries. I think it will be a close race.
Voting ends May 15th!

Saint Michael 001:

Team Destiny 07 001:

livingston 001:

livingston 002:

niru 001:

Mon Apr 30, 2007 Reply New Discussion

develCuy

"niru 001" looks clearer and elegant, but you need something more... common things are not good enough.
Your sites need more colors!. Blue is my favorite, but many blue sometimes change my opinion.
Keep the good ideas. So far good work!!

Tue May 1, 2007 Reply New Discussion

Aniki

Saint Michael and Niru are my favorites. They're both clean and simple, with not too much going on. The reflection effect is nice, too.

Tue May 1, 2007 Reply New Discussion

BOAComm

Really, i dont like no one...
I voted in first.
if its was possible...would like to participate sugesting "the" logo..

CreativeLabs make the difference!

we're just in time to send a new logo, or not?

Tue May 1, 2007 Reply New Discussion

Grafitti

I like Saint Michael's the best. I think he struck a nice balance between simplicity and design. Niru would have gotten my vote as well if there were multiple voting possibilities, but though nice, just a tad too plain for me. He should get some credits though for his favicons, i think those are the best of the bunch.

Tue May 1, 2007 Reply New Discussion

Team Destiny 07

Saint Micheal GMV.

Tue May 1, 2007 Reply New Discussion

Niru

Thanks for each and every guys for such nice comments and sugegstions!

I'm not a good or Professional designer! But I can say that, I tried my level best to get those credits! ( hehehe :ph34r:

)
Anyway, My personal choice will be Saint Michael 001 only!

He had created one nice logo with nice effects!
That will be much better than mine! I like to appreciate Saint Michael for such a wonderful job!

Thanks & regards,
Niru

Wed May 2, 2007 Reply New Discussion

.:Brian:.

I have to say that I really like the simplicity of the last one, niru 001...it is very simple, elegant, and professional.

The first design doesn't trail it by far, and so I also like Saint Michael 001.

However the other designs....i do not care for at all....

1. niru 001
2. Saint Michael 001

Thu May 3, 2007 Reply New Discussion

saint-michael

Although I am not a professional more like a noob with 2 years of experience :ph34r:

, I see some good designs, idea's and professional layouts from everyone and of course good luck to everyone else. If I were able ot multi vote I would place my votes for the following:

niru-favicon
livingston-text effect

Thu May 3, 2007 Reply New Discussion

vujsa

I'm glad to see all of the input I'm getting on thiis topic. I'm looking forward to reading more comments and seeing how the poll results turn out.

Thanks to everyone that submitted a logo set and everyone that has voted and commented on the designs submitted.

vujsa

Wed May 9, 2007 Reply New Discussion

saint-michael

YEAH!!! I won!! I think I put my face in the background somewhere

. I have to say that there were some good designs in this contest for vujsa's site, I like to thanks those who voted for me and stuff

Wed May 16, 2007 Reply New Discussion

WeaponX

I guess it's anonymous then

Saint Michael, you did a great job on that logo. Perhaps a bit lighter in the blue to match the Handy PHP site?

Wed May 16, 2007 Reply New Discussion

xerxes

Although Saint Michael 001 and niru 001 do look much more professional than others, they are graphically elaborate and quite detailed. I agree that they are the best looking ones, but they may not go well with the simple and straightforward design of your webpage, which doesn't even employ any special fonts or animations (to great effect). I think that a logo should fit into a webpage seamlessly, rather that stand out too much, hence I chose livingston 002.

Thu May 17, 2007 Reply New Discussion

vujsa

Well at the time of the deadline, saint-michael was in the lead with Niru following closely behind. Thanks to everyone for participating and voting in this contest. This weekend I will review all of the votes, opinions, and suggestions and make my decision on who will receive the bulk of the credits.

I still haven't figured out how to award credits to saint-michael but every entry will get at least 10 credits! Bet more people wish they had entered the contest now.

Also, I may use a combination method for the final images to be used but I think that most people agree that every entry had something positive to contribute.

I'll reply later with a breakdown of the distribution of credits to the participants after the weekend. Been so busy. Needless to say, this will cost me a lot more than 30 credits.

vujsa

Thu May 17, 2007 Reply New Discussion

Chesso

Bummer, I just voted on niru LOL.

I really liked niru's and actually Sain Micheal's was great too but it reminded me too much of old netscape navigator for some reason.

And LOL @ 10 credits for entrants.

Mon May 21, 2007 Reply New Discussion