Nov 22, 2009
Pages: 1, 2

Windows XP SP2 Better Than SP1? - Should I Upgrade?

free web hosting

Read Latest Entries..: (Post #18) by nightfox on Apr 11 2006, 01:19 PM.
QUOTE(xboxrulz @ Feb 12 2006, 08:09 PM) there are many exploits on SP2, it creates some itself and doesn't patch crap.nonono, it "patches" maybe 2 old holes, but it just opens 5 million new holes! lol Anyway, when I service a Windows XP computer, my boss always has me put on SP1 if they don't already have it. When SP2 was new, pretty much all of my computers couldn't take it. They'd slow down to where an old NEC PowerMate V116e (100 MHz Pentium, 16K or 64K...
read more.
Read the FIRST post of this Topic. - Express your Opinion! Contribute Knowledge :-).

Open Discussion & Free Web Hosting > Computers & Tech > Operating Systems > Windows (All Versions)

Windows XP SP2 Better Than SP1? - Should I Upgrade?

Kushika
I understand that there are alot of security updates in SP2. But I'm not sure if I should upgrade (I'm using Windows XP SP1). I have a decent anti-virus software installed, as well as a few freeware bit 'n' bobs. Also, if new viruses are made, are they exploiting the faults in SP1 or SP2? Or does it not matter which one they target?

Microsoft claims:
QUOTE
The vast majority of users upgrade to SP2 without a hitch, but there are some unusual cases where users have software or hardware configurations that cause problems with starting their computers after they install SP2.


Personally, I'm slightly worried that the installation will fail and that I won't be able to recover my SP1 nor access my computer. I am running on a genuine version of Windows. I've never understood Service Packs, so I'm not sure how serious a fail could be. Any one here know what the worst possible scenario could be? And do you guys think it is worth for me to upgrade?

 

 

 


Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

wutske
There's a been a discussion on this subject before, search function will probably help.
As for me, I still use SP1 and I've never had any security issues, mainly because
a) I have a descent (free) virusscanner, namely Avast wich protects my at different levels
cool.gif I have a descent firewall wich is configured rahter strictly (loooots of blocked ports)
c) I regulary run adware, spybot, etc ...
d) I don't use Internet Exploder, nor outlook express, but I use opera w/ M2

So, you're safe enough w/o SP2, plus, you safe yourself a lot of freaking balloons, pop-ups and other crappy questions that keeps annoying you (I could stand it 10min before I reseted the pc and started intstalling SP1 again laugh.gif ).

Oh, and if you'd want to upgrade to SP2, there normaly arent' issues anymore, so it will prolly run completely flawless. Afterwards you can uninstall SP2 as if it was a normal program.

Oh(2), always make back-up, it sooner to late than you expect.

 

 

 


Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

fishling
there are so many exploits in service pack 1 that you really should update

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

xboxrulz
there are many exploits on SP2, it creates some itself and doesn't patch crap.

The only patch that it gave me is game stability. 3D rendering is fixed with SP2, that's all.

xboxrulz

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

Jeigh
I'd say it's good for people who are complete tech-incompetents, since it sets firewalls and auto-updates on by default. Plus SP2 has a bunch of the security fixes that have been released that are now widely publicized security holes so it would be good to fix them just in case. Personally I'd reccomend it even though it's only annoyed me haha. I ahven't noticed any problems, just annoyances with the security center keeping trying to be more in control then I'll let it tongue.gif

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

Kushika
QUOTE(Jeigh @ Feb 13 2006, 01:03 AM) *

I'd say it's good for people who are complete tech-incompetents, since it sets firewalls and auto-updates on by default.


Are you talking about that rubbish Microsoft firewall that does absolutely nothing? XD It leads to a false sense of in security in my opinion.

Once I actually properly back-up my system, or atleast, the important documents, I'll try to give SP2 a go. By the way, does it take up a lot of file space? I don't mean the initial installation file, but the whole service pack in general? Becuase I'm already using alot of diskspace as it is.

Thanks for your previous replyies guys!

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

sparx
We all agree that SP2 fixes up old holes and also creates new ones. Bottom line is - keep your PC updated with the latest patches. SP2 has been out for quite some time and has had the smallest percentages of install failures in the recorded history of Windows Updates [ barring Win2003Server updates]. As with all major software upgrades, backup to a separate location [ like a CD / DVD ] or another HDD. Prevention is better than having to waste time huntinig and then implementing the cure. If the hole to exploit is absent you won't be infected with the malware designed specifically to look for that hole in your PC.

My opinion - take the plunge. Install SP2 but take the precaution of backing up your data.

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

finaldesign
don't worry too much, just install it. If it won't work, then you probably have pirated version of ms win Xp. smile.gif and then go buy a legal one in store, and everything will work fine..

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

tt3
I would upgrade to SP2. There really isn't any reason why you shouldn't and I'd imagine that more and more Microsoft software or updates will require SP2. I believe the IE7 beta requires Service Pack 2, and no doubt the final release will too.

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

Flash¹³
I've personally never had a problem with SP2, at all. I got one of the 'first' public releases of it (before they quietly added a few fixes) and it hasn't broken since.

Yes the firewall is a bit on the lame side, and the security centre is over zelous at first, but it can all be set up just the way I like it... And I don't see any problems with automatic updates.

All in all, SP2 was one of the least painful updates I've done (after I turned off system restore, damn that takes a long time on this system biggrin.gif).

t33 makes a good point with future compatibility too, and not just MS stuff, I know of lots of programs that require SP2 to work properly smile.gif

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

Latest Entries

nightfox
QUOTE(xboxrulz @ Feb 12 2006, 08:09 PM) *

there are many exploits on SP2, it creates some itself and doesn't patch crap.

nonono, it "patches" maybe 2 old holes, but it just opens 5 million new holes! lol tongue.gif

Anyway, when I service a Windows XP computer, my boss always has me put on SP1 if they don't already have it. When SP2 was new, pretty much all of my computers couldn't take it. They'd slow down to where an old NEC PowerMate V116e (100 MHz Pentium, 16K or 64K of RAM, Win95) was slightly faster. And these were computers which were much faster too... Microsoft support didn't help at all. I think even AOL tech support could have figured this one out.

Tip: NEVER "embed" the new SP until you have VERIFIED it won't slow your system down. When a 1.8 GHz computer begins to "lag" and act really slow just after you installed a new service pack, then remove it. Else if it works fine, remove it and THEN embed it.

[N]F

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

xboxrulz
there isn't much of a difference. The main difference is that it plugged old holes and made new ones.

xboxrulz

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

Kushika
QUOTE(kgd2006 @ Apr 7 2006, 11:56 AM) *

I believe the security in SP2 is upgraded to a really good extent.

It also have its own pop up blocker I believe that prevents them annoying pop ups that we get when we visit sites.

I would definitely reccomend you to get upgraded to SP2, the new secuirty features installed to the system are features I believe you probably cant regret, well thats if you like seeing pop ups...haha


Yes, it does have IE with a pop-up blocker. Nevertheless, I use Firefox so I have a pop-up blocker already. Apart from security fixes, I don't think there's much of a difference between SP1 & 2.

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

kgd2006
I believe the security in SP2 is upgraded to a really good extent.

It also have its own pop up blocker I believe that prevents them annoying pop ups that we get when we visit sites.

I would definitely reccomend you to get upgraded to SP2, the new secuirty features installed to the system are features I believe you probably cant regret, well thats if you like seeing pop ups...haha

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

fcfosters
If u dont upgrade to sp2 some programs refuses to co-operate.. But yes sp2 includes loads of crap.

Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)


Got an Opinion! Express your Views! (no registration):-
Add your Reply/ Opinion/ Views/ Comments/ Suggestion/ Questions/ Queries etc.
Posts with decent grammar & English will be accepted and please refrain from profanities.
For asking a Question, We recommend you to sign-up (for free) so that you can track the topic easily.

Nature of your Post*: Opinion/ Reply/ Comments
Question/Query
Feedback to us.
       
Name   Email
Title/Question*

This textarea will convert to Rich-Text automatically (IE, Firefox, Chrome)

Pages: 1, 2
Similar Topics

Keywords : windows, xp, sp2, sp1, upgrade

  1. Windows 2000
    update to 2009 specs (8)
  2. What Do You Guys Think Of Windows 7?
    The 'WoW' Starts 'NoW' (32)
    What do you guys think of windows 7? Screenshots Have been posted on wikipedia
    (www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_7) and I Must admit Im Not really Impressed, Looks Like a dumbed
    down version of vista...? what are your Opinions?....
  3. Windows Black Edition
    (13)
    Which version of windows is microsoft releasing after Vista?I heard that it is releasing microsoft
    windows black /. Does anybody know about it?....
  4. Windows 7
    (14)
    when will microsoft release windows7? does it have any cool features or new feature? can anyone tell
    me more about this ? thanks.......
  5. Why I May Be Installing Windows Xp Sp3 Again
    (16)
    This is a sad tale of a man and his machine that would not start again. The story continues with a
    sorted affair between two operating systems and a battle to win the love of this man’s heart. My
    problems began last weekend when I started my computer after it had been off from the previous
    night. Everything went normally throughout the POST but once Windows XP started I heard the dreaded
    clicking from the hard drive. After several reboots and a Spinrite diagnostic I gave up and called
    the time of death around three in the afternoon. This is not all bad because I had....
  6. Windows Xp Service Pack 3 - Updates
    (19)
    its been a couple or more year, Microsoft haven't release a 3rd version of their service pack,
    for Micorsoft's Windows XP. In the late 2007, Microsoft had announce of the release of their
    Service Pack 3 for Microsoft Windows XP. Windows XP Service Pack 3 (SP3) is currently in
    development. As of January 2008, Microsoft's web site indicates a "preliminary" release date to
    be in the first half of 2008.A feature set overview has been posted by Microsof and details new
    features available separately as standalone updates to Windows XP, as well as features backpor....
  7. How To Login To An Expired Windows Vista System
    based on How To Login To An Expired Windows Xp System (2)
    I just read How To Login To An Expired Windows Xp System . This gave me a nice Windows Vista
    mini-tutorial. Notice!!! I'm not advertising piracy!! It's just a matter of having
    the rights to access your files, and it doesn't approve that it restores the full function of
    Windows Vista, and besides How To Login To An Expired Windows Vista System 1) Login until you go
    unto the windows where it says that the Windows has expired. 2) Click on the purchase new serial
    key. (yehey!!! /smile.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":)" border="0" alt="s....
  8. Windows 98 Transfer
    Just plug it in? (5)
    Ok as the other topic said, I am planning to purchase a new computer sometime soon. We have Windows
    98 on the old machine and I don't want to throw it out just yet. I need Internet Explorer 6/5.5
    for web page testing and obviously I can't run both Windows Internet Explorer 7 and 6 on Windows
    XP. So I am planning to transfer the entire hard drive over to the new system. A few issues though:
    Will Windows 98 with such "powerful" components? System has 512MB RAM, Intel Pentium 4 3GHz
    processor, 7.1 sound card, integrated video card and DVD+RW burner are the main com....
  9. 100 Reasons To Use Windows Vista
    No, really?? (14)
    Recently, I have received an "Exploring Windows" email from Microsoft, which led me to an
    interesting link called 100 Reasons You'll be speechless. Thought it was related to Windows
    Vista, and it was. Here are some of my opinions: 1. It makes using your PC a breeze, if Windows is
    responding most of the time. Also, many users have complained about User Account Control, which say
    that it makes using the PC not a breeze. I haven't tried it yet, but from others' point of
    view, it seems to be intrusive and annoying. 2. Your music may be a click away from your re....
  10. Windows Vista Is Awesome!
    I've recently got Windows Vista and I've had very few problems (26)
    ATTENTION ALL READERS! WINDOWS VISTA IS AWESOME - I REPEAT - WINDOWS VISTA IS AWESOME! I think
    Windows Vista is an incredibly good operating system which allows you to do so much more than XP.
    The new look, design, simplicity, controls and layout are all fantastic. I've got a clock and a
    calendar on the right hand side of my desktop and all my icons easier and clearer to recognise. It
    takes under 5 seconds to log in and the graphics are just great. I've got Windows Vista Home
    Premium and as long as I install the compatible drivers, all the software works! I'....
  11. How To Login To An Expired Windows Xp System
    (18)
    Disclaimer from the site: QUOTE Disclaimer: I do not applaud piracy, but I do feel people
    should have access to their personal files, regardless of whether Windows has expired or not. This
    tutorial should not be used to bypass Windows Activation, nor does it restore full Windows
    functionality, but I provide it to those who are in desperate need of accessing files that are
    suddenly lost to them through the Microsoft Genuine Advantage activation system. I just
    came across this interesting tutorial. By now, everyone is familiar with Windows XP's....
  12. Help Needed To Create Windows Startup Script!
    (5)
    Hi all, I need a help from any one out here! I need to display one confirmation box using windows
    startup script! I need to run this script on each and every client system in my LAN! Here is the
    requirement: The script should ask the user to click yes to continue or no to exit. If the user
    click yes, that should open Internet Explorer with some site , Say google.com and after filling some
    forms and after closing the browser, that should bring to regular login screen which says, cntrl alt
    del to login! If the user directly preses the no button, that should close the co....
  13. Deleting A Corrupt File
    Cannot delete a corrupt file on Windows XP... (31)
    I was upgrading some software and came across a corrupt file that halted the installation process. I
    went to see what was wrong with the file, and failed to manually delete it. I tried moving
    (cut&paste) it to another location, and the installation succeeded. However, the file is still on my
    drive, taking up a KB of space. I know that's not a lot, but where am I supposed to put it? In a
    folder created especially for all the corrupt files on my computer? /blink.gif"
    style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":blink:" border="0" alt="blink.gif" /> I've heard
    something....
  14. Lock Workstation Shortcut
    How to make a shortcut to lock your windows computer (11)
    1) Right click on desktop and select add new shortcut 2) In the 'Type Location of the item:'
    box type or copy %windir%\System32\rundll32.exe user32.dll,LockWorkStation then click 'next'
    3) In the 'Type a name for this shortcut:' box type or copy "Lock Workstation" and click
    'Finish' 4) Now if you would like go to properties and Change Icon browse to:
    %SystemRoot%\explorer.exe and I use the red circle with the white x ....
  15. Windows XP Folder Encryption Key ?
    Where is the Windows XP encryption Key saved. (15)
    Does any one know where is the encryption key in Windows XP stored. In other words how can one get
    encryption key. Or how to retrive the data without the encrytion key. By encrypting a file or
    folder, we are converting it to a format that can't be read by other people. A file encryption
    key is added to files or folders that you choose to encrypt. This key is needed to read the file.
    ....
  16. Downgrade Windows MCE To XP?
    (9)
    Is it possible to downgrade a Windows Media Center Edition computer to use Windows XP instead?
    Someone is having so much problems with this machine and I think it's the Operating System
    causing the problem. I told her to reinstall Windows MCE, but I don't think they gave her any
    Windows CDs. I think she got it burned from a recovery partition after I told her to look for one.
    But that doesn't seem to work. So I'm thinking of downgrading to XP as a possible solution.
    Isn't Windows MCE very similar to Windows XP, aside from the extra media features? Th....
  17. Windows Xp Bsod Troubles
    (5)
    Our family computer is running Windows XP Home SP2 with all the latest updates installed and we
    constantly get Blue Screens of Death. The most common is DRIVER_IRQL_NOT_EQUAL_OR_LESS in NDIS.sys
    and portcls.sys. I have googled this many times and found nothing to help but I have heard the two
    files are for the network card and sound card respectively. The computer has the following specs:
    - Intel Pentium 4 3.0GHz - Gigabyte 85661FXMP-RZ motherboard with Award v. 6.0 BIOS - NIVIDIA
    GeForce FX 5200 - No idea what the network card and sound cards are but we use the net....
  18. Can You Create A Folder Name "con"
    Is it possible to create a folder named "CON" in Windows? (22)
    I tried in both Windows XP Home and Professional. If you try to make a folder named "CON" Windows XP
    renames it back to what it was. So creating a new folder with the name "CON" just renames it to "New
    Folder". The bug seems like a variable that got treated as a string or vice-versa. Trying to create
    the folder from a cmd prompt failed with an error "The directory name is invalid.". This also works
    when you try to create a file called "CON", or "CON.". ".CON" shows up the way it should. Somewhere
    I found the reason that CON stands for CONsole which is device name but....
  19. The Best Version Of Windows
    (52)
    With all the different flavors of Windows, what in your opinion is the best version? Win95, Win98,
    Win98SE, WinNT, Win2000, WinXP, Vista, and even remember Windows 3.1? I hear that hardcore Windows
    users are in love with Win98SE for some reason? Is there any justification behind this? I mean
    this is a version of Windows that is definitely not supported anymore, but is the security and
    stability of this version that much better where it doesn't need support? Personally, I really
    like Win2000 over any other version. It seems more secure and stable, and I'm pr....
  20. Windows Problems "new Series"- Xp Home Edition Activation Issue
    (7)
    i never used Windows XP Home edition before, in these days i have no way to use it on my work pc,
    have no profissional edition and i don't want to buy one, in fact i hate windows at all, i use
    linux and it's so good and enough to me, but i must use it noway. after i installed it, it asked
    me to activate it, i went into the activation process, finally it told me to call any microsoft
    products reseller or something like that to provide me with a new product number as they say in that
    message: QUOTE According to our records, the number of times you can activ....
  21. Help: Adding My Videos Folder To Start Menu
    Windows XP Only (12)
    Okay, I am halfway to being able to add the My Videos Folder (the only of the special My folder I
    really use) to the start panel. For those of you who don't know what I am talking about, make
    sure you have the new XP start menu not classic, then open your start menu. The right side is the
    start panel, and it should have links to things like My Documents, My Music, My Computer, etc. The
    only one you can't add to it (you add features to it from the properties page) is the My Videos
    File. No, my method: 1) Knowing Windows as well as I do, first thing after ex....
  22. Using Same Serial # On Multiple Copies Of Windows
    (31)
    I heard it is possible to run more than one computers on the same serial of Windows. I also heard
    that it can be registered and use all the functions of any legal copy of Windows. Lets say I have 4
    computers in my house and don't want to pay $800 for windows on each one if I build them all
    myself. I can just put same serial on all of them. But I heard this is also breaking the EULA
    agreement with Microsoft which redeems this being illegal or improper use of windows. I would like
    to hear your sides on this, or the whole truth behind this. If so does this mean somebody....
  23. Chmoding On Windows (apache) ? Howto ?
    (5)
    Hi, I've recently installed Apache 1.3.34 on my Windows XP machine. Does anyone know how to CMOD
    files to specific values? I've read somewhere that if you set the file to 'readable'
    that is the equivalent of CHMODing it to 777...is this true? By the way, sorry if this is in the
    wrong forum section. I wasn't really sure where to put this.....
  24. How To Create "ghost" Images (norton) On Windows
    (53)
    Hi, I'm tired of wasting so much time on a site when I have to reinstall Windows from scratch.
    Want to speed up the process a little since I have to install Windows XP, any Service Packs, Norton
    Antivirus and Microsoft AntiSpyware for the computers. I want to create images of good working
    Window states, but have some questions. 1. How much faster would this be compared to reinstalling
    everything manually? I will be doing this from an external hard drive. 2. What are the chances of
    an image not working assuming that the image created is good? I heard that these ....
  25. Command Line (dos) Tips For Windows Xp
    (7)
    Windows XP cmd tip (DOS isn’t dead... it just smells funny) Some command-line folder creation
    examples: To create multiple folders at once, add them directly to the "md" command: C:\> md this
    is a test To create a folder several folders deep, use: C:\> md this\is\a\test Creating a folder
    with a long name requires the double-quote at the beginning: C:\> md "this is a test Bonus tip:
    Windows XP supports the forward slash "/" as a folder divider. Unix/Linux users: don't let the
    DOS environment get you down. Use a Unix-style CD command to change your present worki....
  26. How To Repair Disk Errors And Bad Sectors
    Windows Xp,2000,Nt (5)
    How to repair disk errors and bad sectors in Windows Xp,2000,NT You can use Windows Disk Manager
    tool to check for file system errors and bad sectors on your hard disk. To check your drives:
    1- right click on drive and click Properties 2- click Tools tab and under Error-checking, click
    Check Now 3- in dialog box select the Automatically fix file system errors or/and Scan for and
    attempt recovery of bad sectors check box Automatically fix file system errors ....
  27. Where Does Windows Xp Store Its Passwords ?
    (18)
    Is thre a file where password information is kept in windows XP? If so what is it's name and
    where is it located?....
  28. A Note To All Illegal Windows Xp Owners
    (55)
    Hi, all illegal Windows XP users WILL NOT be able to download any updates or software from Microsoft
    website. Automatic Updates will no longer work, because Microsoft will have to ask for your Software
    identification.....
  29. How To Increase Windows Shutdown Speed
    when you enabled “clear Page File at shu (45)
    How to increase Windows shutdown speed when you enabled “clear Page File at shutdown”? /blink.gif"
    style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":blink:" border="0" alt="blink.gif" /> Note that making
    incorrectly changes to the registry may damage your system; please back up any valued data on your
    computer. 1) Go to Start menu > Run > and type regedit and click OK. 2) Find following address:
    HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE \ SYSTEM \ CurrentControlSet \ Control \Session Manager \ Memory Management
    3) In right side right click on “ClearPageFileAtShutdown”, select Modify and make value of ....
  30. Windows Not Recognizing Ipod
    (33)
    OK, I'm running Windows XP and my iPod is not detected when I plug it in. The only things that
    I could guess are wrong are that I recently had a trojan, known as BackDoor-AWI and that my router
    flaked out and I have no internet on the computer in question now. I'm not sure what happened,
    but for some reason, McAfee is telling me that it's all screwed up on startup. So it's not
    even running anymore. My computer does recognize USB keys, but will not see my iPod for some
    reason. Any ideas?....

    1. Looking for windows, xp, sp2, sp1, upgrade

See Also,

*SIMILAR VIDEOS*
Searching Video's for windows, xp, sp2, sp1, upgrade
Similar
Windows 2000 - update to 2009 specs
What Do You Guys Think Of Windows 7? - The 'WoW' Starts 'NoW'
Windows Black Edition
Windows 7
Why I May Be Installing Windows Xp Sp3 Again
Windows Xp Service Pack 3 - Updates
How To Login To An Expired Windows Vista System - based on How To Login To An Expired Windows Xp System
Windows 98 Transfer - Just plug it in?
100 Reasons To Use Windows Vista - No, really??
Windows Vista Is Awesome! - I've recently got Windows Vista and I've had very few problems
How To Login To An Expired Windows Xp System
Help Needed To Create Windows Startup Script!
Deleting A Corrupt File - Cannot delete a corrupt file on Windows XP...
Lock Workstation Shortcut - How to make a shortcut to lock your windows computer
Windows XP Folder Encryption Key ? - Where is the Windows XP encryption Key saved.
Downgrade Windows MCE To XP?
Windows Xp Bsod Troubles
Can You Create A Folder Name "con" - Is it possible to create a folder named "CON" in Windows?
The Best Version Of Windows
Windows Problems "new Series"- Xp Home Edition Activation Issue
Help: Adding My Videos Folder To Start Menu - Windows XP Only
Using Same Serial # On Multiple Copies Of Windows
Chmoding On Windows (apache) ? Howto ?
How To Create "ghost" Images (norton) On Windows
Command Line (dos) Tips For Windows Xp
How To Repair Disk Errors And Bad Sectors - Windows Xp,2000,Nt
Where Does Windows Xp Store Its Passwords ?
A Note To All Illegal Windows Xp Owners
How To Increase Windows Shutdown Speed - when you enabled “clear Page File at shu
Windows Not Recognizing Ipod
advertisement



Windows XP SP2 Better Than SP1? - Should I Upgrade?

Affordable Web Hosting, Low cost Web Hosting - ComputingHost.com