Which Is Faster? Dsl Or Cable? - Which is faster???

Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4
free web hosting

Read Latest Entries..: (Post #36) by jipman on Apr 14 2005, 11:54 AM. (Line Breaks Removed)
Notice from jipman: Topic ClosedI think that we've seen enough opinions about this topic
Read the FIRST post of this Topic. - Express your Opinion! Contribute Knowledge :-).

Free Web Hosting > Computers & Tech > Networking

Which Is Faster? Dsl Or Cable? - Which is faster???

sydney28th
OK! Which is faster? DSL or CABLE? Seriously.. I can't tell blink.gif
Some people say cable is faster, but other people say that now dsl matches the speed of cable or it's better or something ohmy.gif
So.. I'm kind of confused... I have DSL and it's pretty fast, while my friend has CABLE... which.. her's is a bit slow.. (maybe its her computer??)
Anyway, someone help me out ohmy.gif
Which is faster? DSL or CABLE?...
(if only i had t3.. that would solve everything.. *sigh* tongue.gif)

Reply

Trekkie101
I would like a DS3 line that would be really cool, could download linux distros in minutes. Im with ADSL and its pretty fast, no idea though, cant egt cable where i live.

Reply

marijnnn
wel, in belgium, they say the max cable speed to be around 6.6mbps

dsl should be able to get speeds up to 8mbps, but that'll cost you quite a lot too i think

next to that, i think cable is still being limited because servers can't handle it.
it apears to me that cable should be able to become faster as the signal travels faster... not sure though.

one thing is for sure: if you live in a forgotten place, go for cable. dsl slows down the further you are away from the server

Reply

mastercomputers
QUOTE(marijnnn @ Nov 15 2004, 03:17 AM)
wel, in belgium, they say the max cable speed to be around 6.6mbps

dsl should be able to get speeds up to 8mbps, but that'll cost you quite a lot too i think

next to that, i think cable is still being limited because servers can't handle it.
it apears to me that cable should be able to become faster as the signal travels faster... not sure though.

one thing is for sure: if you live in a forgotten place, go for cable. dsl slows down the further you are away from the server
*



We can get 10Mbps or 100Mbps Cable here which can be connected to a 100Mbps Fibre Optic network, but only available in Central Business District and well over most people's budget.

ADSL can reach speeds up to 8Mbps but it's not guaranteed to run at that rate, Wireless has similar speeds but is only good for downloading only.

Which is faster can not be said, if you opt for 2Mbit ADSL vs 2Mbit Cable, it should be the same, only limitations can be said by line condition, ISP, shared, your location, etc

Cheers,


MC

 

 

 


Reply

Herbert
Wow, all this tech talk, and I was just going to express my personal experience! sad.gif
Ah well. From what I've seen (around my area) the most I ever squeezed out of my cable modem was 450kbps and that was from downloading Linux isos from multiple servers. At the same time, I hear people I know with DSL boasting 96kbps speeds, and I just chuckle inside my head... Then I laugh out loud laugh.gif


Of course, at the same time, I know a guy that is hooked into an OC3 internet connection, and when I ask him if he had an such and such 700 meg iso and he said "no"... 5 minutes later he'd say "ok, got it!" blink.gif

Reply

lhunath
OC3, *drool*

One:
Cable & DSL speeds depend on what your provider caps you on and what your modem can handle. My connection is capped at 6.6Mbit/s, meaning a max of 660Kb/s download speed. But my modem can handle 40Mbit/s (aka 4Mb/s download).

Two:
The server you're downloading from is the biggest factor. They most often have a speed limit as well; depending on how you use them; that can be 5kb/s, 20kb/s; 300kb/s; 1Mb/s; ......
If you have a connection that can go 660Kb/s, and the server you're downloading from can only send at 5Kb/s, then u can get a connection as fast and expensive as you want to, you won't download any faster...

Three:
Cable is a shared net, therefore, if your max speed is 660Kb/s, and you have lots and lots of people in your neighbourhood downloading at the same time; you will not be able to reach that maximum. Because the shared net is being saturated. There's actually a max limit for each Hub (the master of one small shared network of a cable distribution, you, your neighbours, and ppl living in your street/block, ..) and when alot of ppl download, you come too close to the max limit, so you can't download as fast anymore.

Reply

Tweak37
It totaly depends on the provider. Here in Belgium, we have two big isp's. One is cable and one is adsl/vdsl. Max speed for adsl is 8 mbps, but vdsl can handle 50 mbps, and will be available soon. Cable is now @10 mbps, but eurodocis 2 can change that too.

Cable has other bad point, like the shared net as lhunath said and downlaod volume limitations.

Reply

haseeb
In my country Pakistan dsl is faster than cable.So im with dsl.I have a cable connection but it runs so slow.But i have some tricks to fast the speed.So i have no problem with cable but dsl faster than cable.
ok biggrin.gif

Reply

Darren
Cable would probably be faster where i live because not many people would have it, however i would always get adsl ove cable because it's so much more reliable. I like to have a consistant speed all the time so i can better judge how long it will take to download thing etc.

Reply

XeroTolerence
this one is almost as debatable as windows vs. linux. cable is faster down, some dsl is faster up. so its really wut u want to use ur inet conn for. if u want to run a basic ftp server or any other server. dsl is good. but if u want fast internet speeds and d/l speeds. cable is the way to go... im talkin about real dsl too, not that crappy hickory tech and some others that come with phone service as well. smile.gif

Reply

Latest Entries

jipman
Notice from jipman:

Topic Closed

I think that we've seen enough opinions about this topic

Reply

amkint
don't know...
i have to work on wireless broadband from my cell phone as my college and hostel is some some corner of bangalore where gettin a phone line can be difficult!! but there are lots of cell towers around so no problem :-)

Reply

xtron
People!!!!!!!!!!!!! don't make me green with envy !!
Ok so i live in the biggest dump in the world (Romania) here i have a cable connection with this specs:
1 suposed 2 get 256 d/l but i get 70 if the sun is heating the cable
2 the thing i wander is that i get 300 at u/l ????? not all the time but this does not comphort me
3 and i PAY 50 USD /month for this s**t !!
4 DSL is only in it's beginings so i can't say squat !!

Reply

mongos
cable is faster, but it's more delicate than DSL !

Reply

LoipsD
I have never had a cable connection so I won't comment on that part.

Currently I have a DSL connection which is prefectly fine. Altough sometimes it doesnt work as well as I would like it to, it gets the job done. I think you should look at the pricing of both and decide for yourself.

Reply


Got an Opinion! Express your Views! (no registration):-
Add your Reply/ Opinion/ Views/ Comments/ Suggestion/ Questions/ Queries etc.
Posts with decent grammar & English will be accepted and please refrain from profanities.
For asking a Question, We recommend you to sign-up (for free) so that you can track the topic easily.

Nature of your Post*: Opinion/ Reply/ Comments
Question/Query
Feedback to us.
       
Name   Email
Title/Question*

(Maximum characters: 10,000)
You have characters left.

Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4
Similar Topics

Keywords : faster, dsl, cable, faster

  1. Intel Processors
    Which is faster? (14)
  2. Two Connections For Faster Internet?
    (10)
    When dialup was common, I heard about people connecting two phone lines so it was faster. Could I do
    that with broadband, the router delivers 12mbps, but I get about 2.5, and I have a extra cable.....
  3. Open_basedir And E-accelerator To Be Activated
    Faster and Secured Hosting. (5)
    Faster and Secured Hosting. ComputingHost will be activating open_basedir
    permissions on all its servers. Previously, we had it active on only a few select servers, however
    to make our hosting envoirment secure, We have now decided to activate it throughout our cluster.
    Some of you might be wondering, What is open_basedir protection exactly? Open_basedir
    limits the files that can be opened by PHP to the specified directory-tree, including the file
    itself. This directive is NOT affected by whether Safe Mode is turned On or Off. If you....
  4. Load Firefox Faster
    (1)
    I've been researching how to load firefox faster. So better follow this steps: 1. Go to the
    schortcut of firefox and click on it. 2. Then put this in the target tab /Prefetch:1 so the line
    will look like this : C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe" /Prefetch:1 Note: use space
    between exe" and /prefetch:1 It really works on me.....
  5. Making Xp Starts 60% Faster
    Making your windows xp starts faster and avoid hang ups. (3)
    By the way this is not my post I have found it in my pc and I forgot the source of it. I'll just
    share it here.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ------------------------- QUOTE Making Windows XP Start 60% Faster Stopping Unneeded Startup
    Services Along with the core operating system and programs that Windows XP runs when it starts,
    there is also a host of services involved. Many of these services are necessary for Windows XP to
    operate correctly. However, many of them are for features in Wind....
  6. How To Make Windows Xp Faster
    (30)
    hello does somwane have tips to let windows xp start up faster are there special programmas for or
    somthing like thate thanks fore youre time....
  7. Cable Internet Connection Requires Aol To Go Online?
    (17)
    Just took a look at one of my user's computer and found a very strange problem. For some odd
    reason, he must sign into AOL in order to use his internet. I would understand if this is required
    if he is using AOL as his main connection, but he is using a dedicated cable service line. The same
    thing is happening to his other computer (requires him to sign onto AOL first before he can
    connect). After playing around with it for a while, Internet Explorer connected without
    AOHell's assistance. I made sure AOL was completely signed off and tried a few more websites and....
  8. New Xbox 360s Shipping With Upgraded Dvd Drive
    New BenQ supplied drive is quieter, faster. (1)
    QUOTE(ign.com) New Xbox 360s Shipping with Upgraded DVD Drive New BenQ supplied drive is
    quieter, faster. by Gerry Block February 6, 2007 - Xbox-Scene.com, a long standing community of
    Xbox and 360 hackers and modders, exposed an unpublicized, yet positive, upgrade to the Xbox
    360's hardware. According to sources, a portion of Xbox 360s produced from November '06
    onwards are incorporating a new, quieter DVD drive. Previous 360s have used Toshiba-Samsung and
    Hitachi-LG drives, the sources of the 360's characteristic whirr. The new DVD drives,
    manufacture....
  9. Ide To Sata Adapters & Power Cable Splitters
    (8)
    Been thinking of using these converters on my IDE hard drives so they are 'SATA
    compliant'. I see that it will be using both the SATA type power connector and also a 4 pin
    (floppy drive type) connector. Have anyone used these IDE to SATA adapters before? Are both power
    cables required in order to make a drive operational? I will also be getting a SATA PCMCIA card for
    my laptop and that's where this will play a important role. I have no idea how to give it power
    if I want to use it as an external...what kind of cable to get for external use (4 pin connector....
  10. Games For Samsung D900
    Install games with data cable (3)
    Hello everyone. I have a problem and perhaps you can help me out? I have a samsung d900 and I want
    to install games using a data cable. Does anyone know how to do it? Thanks in advance!....
  11. Where Can I Find Mobile / Cell Freeware For My Data Cable?
    (5)
    Please assist me, O Astahost gurus! I just got a data cable to connect my LG CG225 cell phone to my
    computer through a USB port so that I can transfer audio and image files back and forth without
    using my cell to connect to the internet and thereby pay fees. The cable works fine, but the
    software that came with it (Mobile Action) doesn't work. I was able to go to the MA website and
    find an updated driver and management software for my phone, but that software will only allow me to
    send SMS messages (without attached audio files or images) and to sync up my contact....
  12. Eiffel
    Faster, Easier, Smarter... (1)
    Hi, Just wanted to check if anyone there knows Eiffel? Eiffel is not well known language that was
    created in 1986 by Bertrand Meyer. Eiffel has many implementations, one from it's author -
    implementation free for Open Source projects and very costy for others... but Eiffel also has one
    fully OpenSource implementation... so what is so good about it that it's worth to learn other
    language? Let's just write few things that are connected to SmartEiffel - Open Source
    implementation of Eiffel: - first of all - it's very powerfull object oriented language - o....
  13. Make Your Web Applications Faster
    (0)
    With the advent of broadband connectivity, the websites are nowadays loading much more faster than
    the past without much optimisation. But at the same time, the visitors are probably looking for
    something more faster. They are not in a mood to wait for more than a few seconds to see the
    requsted url being loaded. So, in view of this changing scenario one needs to optimise webpages so
    that they load faster. So here is the brief guideline you may follow to make it load your webpages
    faster. 1. Load as much information as you can when a page loads for the first time. Use ....
  14. Cable Modem Keeps Rebooting
    (10)
    Everyday my cable modem keeps disconnecting me. I get disconnected at least 3 times a day. I tried
    reformatting my computer to see if any viruses is causing it. After reformatting it worked but after
    upgrading it to service pack 4, it happened again. Is it the computer that's causing this or the
    cable modem. The cable modem is pretty new, it's only 4 months old. Can someone help me with
    this?....
  15. Dropping Off-line
    Any way to test a Cable Modem or Router? (2)
    I've been having this problem lately of dropping off-line (always on, cable access) I
    use to have to cycle (unplug and replug) the Cable Modem and the Router (wired Router) in sequence
    to get back on-line. So I replaced the Cable Modem and Router. Now I'm dropping offline less
    often, and I can get back on by just cycling the Router. Q. Is there anyway to "test" a Cable Modem
    and/or Router to see for sure where the "stoppage" is? ....
  16. Cable Sharing Problem
    ..unequal bandwidth (4)
    I have a 128k connection that is shared between 6 computers. one computer connects directly to the
    internet and the others connect through this shared connection. Now I know that already, this is not
    a good idea, because 128k split over so many will really slow it down, but until I can get a second
    line there's really no way around it. And I know that the host computer will take the lion's
    share of the bandwidth. My question is: How can I make sure that the remaining speed is divided
    equally between the other computers? Right now one or two other computers will ....
  17. Internet Through Data Cable
    (8)
    hi guys, I use internet a lot. I am currently using internet via dial-up connection. I am planning
    to activate internet on my mobile phone. What shall i be needing to use internet on my computer
    using the mobile connection. I have seen that some people access internet using bluetooth. Does the
    use of data cable reduces the speed of internet. Kindly supply your valuable comments on how should
    i go about accessing internet using a mobile phone. Waiting for reply. ....
  18. VGA Monitor Cable Problems
    (8)
    My cousin's computer seems to have a bad VGA monitor cable. The problem is that when I turn it
    on, it seems to be ok, it says auto-configure....then it goes blank (orange light on monitor power
    button). I looked at the VGA connector pins and see that pins 4 and 11 are missing. Just to be
    curious, I looked at the end connected to the LCD and it's also missing pins 4 and 11. Is this a
    coincidence? From what I found, these are what it corresponds to: 4 ID2 Monitor ID Bit 2 11
    ID0 Monitor ID Bit 0 Is this responsible for the shot display and then blank screen? ....
  19. Quicksilver Forums Faster Than phpBB By 15%!
    (6)
    According to one of the lead developers of Quicksilver Forums, he ran a test and found that QSF is
    faster than phpBB: QUOTE(Geoff) A test conducted on http://qsforums.sourceforge.net with
    1000 hits each on a sample page for phpBB and Quicksilver Forums. The generation time for
    Quicksilver Forums: 1629 milliseconds. For phpBB: 1927 milliseconds. See the raw data here. QSF is
    feature packed, easy to modify and 15% faster than phpBB. Which forum software would you choose? The
    QSF 1.1.6 release is just days away and includes speed improvements! Source: Quicks....
  20. Wifiber Technology - New Wireless That Is Faster Than Fiber!
    (8)
    Copied from http://www.engadget.com/2006/02/22/new-wir...ter-than-fiber/ QUOTE New wireless
    "WiFiber" tech faster than fiber? Virginia startup GigaBeam set their sights high with their
    new wireless system: they're taking on fiber. They dub the tech "WiFiber," and are positioning
    the product as a replacement for fiber optic pipes in situations when they're too expensive, too
    harmful to the environment, or just too slow to deploy, and they're claiming one gigabit per
    second speeds to sweeten the deal. WiFiber operates in the 71-76, 81-86, and 92-95....
  21. Cable Modems Uncaping.
    Motorola SB5100(e) (2)
    So, I looked at tcniso.org but they only sell firmwares with his own made flashers. Or already
    uncapped modems. Does anyone have this firmware? Or howto made this flasher. Maybe anyone have
    scheme? /rolleyes.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":rolleyes:" border="0"
    alt="rolleyes.gif" /> ....
  22. Why Is Broadband Cable (CAT5) So Expensive ?
    (12)
    I've been getting into doing wired networking for my house and I've just been wondering why
    Cat5 cable is so expensive? I just got a 15 cable a month or so ago and the crap took $30 out of my
    pocket when just the other day I asked one of my buddies for some cat5 from the place he hangs out
    and BOOM 25 feet of cat5 for F-R-E-E! I have to admit that it isn't the best looking thing in
    the world but still why pay so much cash just for looks?....
  23. Remove Window Animation - Make It Run Faster
    (8)
    make your computer run a little faster. You can shut off the animation displayed when you minimize
    and maximize Windows. 1. Open RegEdit 2. Go to HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Control panel
    \Desktop\WindowMetrics 3. Create a new string value "MinAnimate". 4. Set the value data of 0 for Off
    or 1 for On this should put less stress on your graphics card if you have an older computer.....
  24. Need Tips On Booting Faster (windows)?
    Need help booting up faster. (22)
    Can anyone tell me some tricks to speed up my boot time casue now it takes like 5 minutes.....
  25. Shutdown Windows Xp Faster
    (13)
    Hi So sorry my en is not good . I Learned This tutorial by Byron Hinson And i want teach to u today
    1 - Start Regedit. 2 - Navigate to HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE/SYSTEM/CurrentControlSet/Control. 3 - Click on
    the "Control" Folder. 4 - Select "WaitToKillServiceTimeout" 5 - Right click on it and select Modify.
    6 - Set it to a value lower than 2000, say 1000 as a test by 6 Steps you can make windows faster to
    shutdown some body dont know what is Regedit , Regedit is Regsitery Editor And for run this APP go
    to Start menu and then RUN and then Type in Run Regedit .....
  26. Extension Cable Fixes My Broken USB2 But Why ?
    this is insane ! (1)
    Let me start off by saying although i talk alot about linux here, the broblm occusr both under linux
    and winowsXP. but linux reports error messages alot better than windows (which just denies the
    device is even plugged in) so ive talked about linux more. But the problem itself is Hardware, so
    for you windows users, please dont stop reading. Ii need your help too! thanks.
    =============================================================================== Hello guys. Im
    going to explain this all step by step because the solution the edidence points to just doesnt make
    senc....
  27. Hosting Credit Countdown
    Does Hosting Plan 2 lose them faster? (2)
    I was wondering whether the more comprehensive hosting plan uses up hosting credits more quickly.
    Surely there must be some sort of discrepancy between what is required for Hosting Plan 1 and what
    is required for Hosting Plan 2. As a bonus, do any of you know how much faster hosting credits are
    lost on Hosting Plan 2?....
  28. Help Me : Boot With Cable
    (2)
    i've a problem i just configurated a PC , but when i wanna boot the windows the system show me
    error coz i'm not connected with a net cable, when i connect him the windows is loaded without
    any problem ... i've already disabled the Network but still does the same thing , can you help
    me ou ?....
  29. Firefox Speed Tweaks
    How to make Firefox open websites faster (15)
    Note: The one posted here is not the same thing. This one has been tested and increases the
    speed, an update to perform these same steps is avalailable on the mozilline.org forums as well.
    Type in the Address Bar - about:config Then scroll over to the following settings and adjust:
    network.http.max-connections :40 network.http.max-connections-per-server :20
    network.http.max-persistent-connections-per-server :20 network.http.pipelining :True
    network.http.pipelining.maxrequests :32 network.http.proxy.pipelining :True Taken from here ....
  30. Want A Faster Game Graphics?
    Do you have a slow nvidia gpu? (2)
    Ever heard of coolbits? if you knew that very good... but if not, coolbits is a good tweaking stuff
    for nvidia gpus. Registry modification required. try searching the net coolbits 2... enjoy playing
    faster.......

    1. Looking for faster, dsl, cable, faster






*SIMILAR VIDEOS*
Searching Video's for faster, dsl, cable, faster
advertisement




Which Is Faster? Dsl Or Cable? - Which is faster???



 

 

 

 

ADD REPLY / Got an Opinion! a humble request :-) RAPID SEARCH! Free Hosting [X]
Express your Opinions, Thoughts or Contribute your information that might help someone here.
Ask your Doubts & Queries to get answers.. "Together, We enlight each other!"
Register FREE for AD-FREE forum, Create your own topics, Ask Questions, track topics, setup subscriptions & notifications and Get a Free Website w/ Email and FTP.
500MB Space *No Ads*, CPanel, FTP, PHP, MySQL, EMails - 100% FREE